System One 模型经过训练,能够理解结构。
哪里可以使用结构
以下每个字段的类型都是 EntryType。
| 字段 | 适用于 | 接受的形态 |
|---|---|---|
instructions | Choice、Score、Noul | string、object、array 或 null |
criteria 的值(选项描述) | Choice | string、object、array 或 null |
criteria 的条目(级别描述) | Score | string、object、array 或 null |
criteria.true 和 criteria.false | Noul | string、object、array 或 null |
什么时候该给问题加上结构
- 当它有助于表达清晰时。 当一个问题由多个部分组成时,把它写成 JSON 形式有助于清晰,因为各个键都有标签。
- 当问题需要辅助数据时。 schema、分类体系或数据库行本身就是 JSON。直接整体使用这份 JSON,或传入相关的子字段,而不是把它们序列化进字符串模板。
结构化 instructions
一个 field 对象描述被检查的字段,每个问题通过键引用它。同样的结构既驱动校验取值的 Noul,也驱动从候选中挑选的 Choice,还驱动把取值放到量表上的两个 Score。
{
"state": {
"source_text": "Invoice #4471 issued March 3, 2026 to Beaver Dam Logistics for $12,840.00, net 30."
},
"questions": {
"invoice_number_is_correct": {
"type": "noul",
"instructions": {
"field": {
"name": "invoice_number",
"type": "string",
"description": "The identifier printed on the invoice."
},
"extracted_value": "4471",
"question": "Does `extracted_value` match the `field` as it appears in `source_text`?"
}
},
"customer_name": {
"type": "choice",
"instructions": {
"field": {
"name": "customer_name",
"type": "string",
"description": "The organization the invoice was issued to."
},
"question": "Which option is the value of `field` in `source_text`?"
},
"criteria": {
"Beaver Logistics": null,
"Dam Logistics": null,
"Beaver Dam Logistics": null,
"Beaver": null,
"Dam": null
}
},
"amount_due": {
"type": "score",
"instructions": {
"field": {
"name": "amount_due",
"type": "number",
"unit": "USD",
"description": "The total the invoice asks to be paid."
},
"question": "How large is the `field` value in `source_text`?"
},
"criteria": [
"Under $1,000",
"$1,000 to $10,000",
"$10,000 to $100,000",
"$100,000 to $1,000,000",
"Over $1,000,000"
]
},
"payment_terms": {
"type": "score",
"instructions": {
"field": {
"name": "payment_terms",
"type": "integer",
"unit": "days",
"description": "Days allowed for payment, from terms such as \"net 30\"."
},
"question": "How many days does the `field` in `source_text` allow for payment?"
},
"criteria": [
"Due on receipt",
"Net 10",
"Net 30",
"Net 60",
"Net 90"
]
}
}
}在代码中,你可以遍历潜在的记录,为每个字段构造一个这样的问题,然后全部放进一次调用发送。结构化数据抽取级联实战手册做的就与此类似。
数组也可以。当 instruction 是一份要检查或要比对的内容清单时,可以使用数组:
"instructions": {
"question": "Does the claimed sender identity conflict with the sending domain?",
"compare": ["ticket.sender.display_name", "ticket.sender.email"],
"focus": "Compare the named organization with the email domain."
}
结构化 Choice 选项
Choice 的选项描述同样可以是结构化对象。
用 JSON 评分标准澄清边界
{
"state": "I ordered the standing desk two weeks ago and tracking still says label created. Was I even charged?",
"questions": {
"department": {
"type": "choice",
"instructions": {
"question": "Which team should handle this message?",
"focus": "Classify the customer's primary request, not every topic mentioned."
},
"criteria": {
"billing": {
"what": "Charges, invoices, refunds, or subscriptions",
"not_for": "Order tracking or account access",
"examples": [
"I was charged twice",
"Where is my refund?"
]
},
"orders": {
"what": "Order status, delivery, cancellation, or returns",
"not_for": "Charges or account access",
"examples": [
"Where is my package?",
"Cancel my order"
]
},
"account": {
"what": "Login, password, profile, or security",
"not_for": "Charges or delivery",
"examples": [
"I can't log in",
"Change my email"
]
}
}
}
}
}这个示例告诉模型每个选项涵盖什么、不涵盖什么,从而锐化选项之间的边界。
遍历分类体系
要按深层分类体系做分类,每层问一个 Choice,并在代码中遍历这棵树。每一步的选项是当前节点的子节点,每个选项的值是该子节点的子树。这样模型在选定某个分支之前就能看到分支之下有什么;当条目所属的叶子仅凭分支名并不明显时,这一点很重要。
这里的状态是一条商品信息,第一个问题选择顶层部门。
{
"state": "32oz plastic bottle with a flip straw lid. Fits most bike cages.",
"questions": {
"department": {
"type": "choice",
"instructions": "Which top-level department does this product belong to?",
"criteria": {
"Sporting Goods": {
"Cycling": [
"Bike Bottles & Cages",
"Bike Lights",
"Helmets"
],
"Fitness": [
"Yoga Mats",
"Resistance Bands"
],
"Outdoor": [
"Tents",
"Sleeping Bags",
"Hydration Packs"
]
},
"Home & Kitchen": {
"Drinkware": [
"Water Bottles",
"Travel Mugs",
"Tumblers"
],
"Cookware": [
"Pots & Pans",
"Bakeware"
]
},
"Baby & Toddler": [
"Sippy Cups",
"Bottle Warmers",
"Bibs"
]
}
}
}
}这个瓶子放在两个部门下都说得通。展示子树让模型看到 Sporting Goods > Cycling > Bike Bottles & Cages 和 Home & Kitchen > Drinkware > Water Bottles 两条路径都存在,从而在“商品强调自行车水壶架”与“日常水杯”之间权衡。这个答案上的 probabilities 会告诉你两者的差距是否小到值得同时探索两个分支。
选定部门后,就用该部门的子节点作为选项、它们的子树作为值再问下一个 Choice,如此往复直到抵达叶子。在代码中,这可以是对嵌套字典的循环,每个问题的 criteria 就是当前节点。层级分类实战手册展示了一个类似的遍历树的例子,其中包括在概率接近时让多条候选路径并存的束搜索。
子树可能变得很大。如果某个分支过大,就把值裁剪为它的直接子节点和一部分叶子样本。
结构化 Score 级别
Score criteria 数组中的每一项都可以是对象。
{
"state": "Fixed the null check in the payment handler. Also refactored the retry loop while I was in there, and bumped the SDK version since the old one had that timeout bug.",
"questions": {
"pr_scope": {
"type": "score",
"instructions": {
"question": "How focused is this pull request description on a single change?",
"note": "Judge the number of independent changes, not the size of any one change."
},
"criteria": [
{
"summary": "One change, clearly stated",
"signals": [
"A single fix or feature",
"Nothing described as \"also\" or \"while I was in there\""
]
},
{
"summary": "One main change plus a small related tweak",
"signals": [
"A primary change and one minor adjacent edit",
"The tweak supports the main change"
]
},
{
"summary": "Several independent changes bundled together",
"signals": [
"Two or more unrelated fixes or features",
"Changes that could each be their own PR"
]
}
]
}
}
}结构化 Noul criteria
Noul 的 criteria 是可选的;当是/否边界比较微妙时,结构化的 true 和 false 描述让你可以用定义和两侧各自的示例把边界钉牢。
{
"state": {
"sender": {
"display_name": "Beaver Dam Builders Ltd.",
"email": "donotreply@payroll.example"
},
"message": "Your Q3 bonus is ready. Reply with your login password so we can verify your identity and release the funds."
},
"questions": {
"requests_credentials": {
"type": "noul",
"instructions": {
"question": "Does the `message` ask the recipient to disclose a sensitive credential?",
"inspect": "message",
"focus": "Look for a request to send the credential itself, not a request to change or reset it."
},
"criteria": {
"true": {
"what": "Asks the recipient to reply with, type, or send a password, PIN, one-time code, or other security sensitive answer",
"examples": [
"Reply with your password",
"Send us the 6-digit code you just received"
]
},
"false": {
"what": "No sensitive credential is requested",
"examples": [
"Reset your password from the settings page",
"Your statement is ready"
]
}
}
}
}
}